Standing timber is an asset that moves independently of the dirt underneath it. Selling without knowing what you have is how owners give away the most valuable part of the property.
A timber tract is really two things sold together: the land, and the standing timber on it. They are valued differently, they appreciate on different clocks, and a buyer who understands timber will price both while a seller who does not will price neither.
Pennsylvania has serious hardwood. Black cherry, red and white oak, hard maple and ash from this state move into domestic and export markets, and the value difference between a well stocked mature stand and a tract that was high graded twenty years ago is enormous on the same acreage and the same view.
The decisions that matter most come before listing, not during it.
A timber cruise is a licensed forester's inventory of what is standing: species, diameter, grade, volume, and an estimate of current market stumpage value. It typically costs a fraction of one percent of what the timber is worth, and it is the single highest return expenditure available to a timberland seller.
Without one you are negotiating blind. Buyers who harvest for a living will have their own cruise done, and if you have not, the information is entirely one sided. I have seen tracts listed on raw per acre comparables when the standing timber alone was worth more than the asking price.
A cruise also answers the question every timberland owner asks, which is whether to cut before selling.
Sometimes yes, often no, and it depends on who the likely buyer is.
If the stand is mature, if prices for your dominant species are strong, and if the likely buyer is a recreational or residential buyer who is paying for the view and the hunting rather than the board feet, then taking the timber and selling the land can net more than selling them together. A properly managed selective harvest can also improve the stand.
If your likely buyer is an investor or a neighbouring landowner who values the timber, cutting removes exactly what they were buying. A fresh clearcut also makes a property look wrecked to recreational buyers for several years, and skid trails and a torn up landing read as damage even when the harvest was done well.
Taking a quick, unsupervised, diameter limit cut from whoever knocked on the door. That is high grading. It maximises the logger's margin and can halve the long term value of the stand. If you harvest, use a consulting forester who represents you rather than the mill, and sell the timber by sealed bid.
Pennsylvania's Act 319 preferential assessment has a forest reserve category specifically for land stocked with trees and capable of producing timber, and a great deal of Pennsylvania timberland is enrolled under it. The usual ten acre threshold applies.
The important point for a seller is the same as on any enrolled parcel. A sale does not trigger rollback. A change of use does, and rollback is seven years of tax difference plus six percent simple interest, with a change of use on any portion capable of triggering it across the entire parcel. Timber harvesting itself does not normally constitute a change of use out of forest reserve, but converting ground to building lots certainly does.
Thirty days notice to the county assessor is required before a change of use. Full detail is in the Clean & Green guide.
In two parts. The land is valued on comparable sales for similar wooded acreage, factoring access, terrain, frontage and recreational appeal. The standing timber is valued separately through a timber cruise, which inventories species, diameter, grade and volume and applies current stumpage prices. A tract with mature, well stocked hardwood can be worth several times a similar sized tract that was high graded, even though they look alike from the road.
A timber cruise is a licensed forester's measured inventory of the standing timber: species, volume in board feet, grade and estimated stumpage value. If you are selling a tract with meaningful timber on it, yes. It usually costs a small fraction of the timber value and it is the only way to negotiate from the same information a timber buyer already has.
It depends on your likely buyer. If the buyer is recreational and paying for the view, the hunting and the cabin site, harvesting first and selling the land afterwards can net more. If the buyer is an investor or a neighbour who values the timber, cutting removes the thing they were paying for. What you should never do is take an unsupervised diameter limit cut from a logger who knocked on the door, which is high grading and can halve the long term value of the stand.
High grading is removing the most valuable stems and leaving the poor ones. It pays well once and damages the stand for decades, because what regenerates comes from the genetics and the seed source you left behind. Buyers with any forestry knowledge can spot a high graded tract immediately and will price accordingly. If you are buying, ask for the harvest history.
Yes. Act 319 includes a forest reserve category for land stocked with trees and capable of producing timber, and the usual ten acre threshold applies. Enrolment can reduce the assessed value substantially. The trade off is rollback exposure, which is seven years plus six percent simple interest if the use changes.
Normally no. A timber harvest is generally consistent with the forest reserve use rather than a change out of it. What does trigger rollback is converting the ground to a non qualifying use, such as building lots. Because the rules are applied county by county and a change on any portion can expose the whole parcel, confirm with the county assessment office before a large harvest and give the thirty days notice required before any change of use.
Very. Timber a logging truck cannot reach is worth far less, because harvest cost comes straight out of the stumpage price offered. Legal deeded access rather than a handshake right of way, a road that will carry loaded trucks, workable stream crossings and somewhere to build a landing all matter. Landlocked timber tracts sell at a steep discount for exactly this reason.
Not quite. All timberland is wooded, but plenty of wooded land has little merchantable timber on it, whether because it is young, poorly stocked, previously high graded or on ground too steep to harvest economically. Wooded land is often bought for recreation, hunting or a cabin site. Wooded land is often bought for recreation, hunting or a cabin site rather than for the timber itself.
Before you list a timber tract, or accept an offer on one, find out what is actually standing on it. I can point you to a consulting forester and tell you how the land itself should be priced.
Get My Farm's Value